Fungi Forums
Video Games => Mario Chat => Topic started by: Tv_Themes on October 02, 2009, 09:39:15 PM
-
Christmas of 1995 was rather lackluster for me. I blame this on my list of gifts sent to Santa, the only thing I put on it was "Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island." Well, I got it but nothing else from jolly old St. Nick, but I did get other scattered gifts from family and friends.
So for the rest of 1995 and the beginning of 1996, I spent a lot of time on Yoshi's Island. Because of this, I was constantly plagued by one of the most annoying things in any game; the obnoxious wailing Baby Mario would make when Yoshi lost him.
At the time my bedroom was right next to my grandparents, so my grandmum would often walk past my bedroom, thus she would hear it plenty of times. One time she walked past my room as I was playing and said "I hate that singing tape." Confused, I ask her "What singing tape?" She answers "HEY?! HEY?! HEY?!"
Regardless, Yoshi's Island was a good game, but it was plagued by graphics that NEED to stay where it is. You have no idea how tired I am of seeing Yoshi's Island graphics in SMW hacks, but I digress.
-
Is this another pseudo-fan-fiction or is this a game review?
I honestly can't tell.
-
Its not a psuedo-fan fic, but more like a commentary.
-
Criticizing one of the best looking, most visually captivating games on SNES for its graphics is not very cool.
-
Criticizing one of the best looking, most visually captivating games on SNES for its graphics is not very cool.
Did I bring up Super Mario RPG, Donkey Kong Country or Final Fantasy VI (III)? I don't think so.
-
I love that from anyone else, this topic would've been one big troll attempt. With Tv_Themes, it's just his honest opinion digging his reputation's own grave.
But seriously, aside from the annoying Baby Mario wailing, Yoshi's Island is a great game, especially considering the graphics.
-
I don't interpret what he says at the end there as a knock at YI's graphics, but rather a statement that they're so distinct that they really clash with other graphical styles--which is true (and though I don't play many Mario fan games, I'd have to agree that the use of Yoshi's Island sprites in the ones I did play stuck out terribly).
-
Come on people, I'm only posting my experiences with the game. If I didn't like the graphics, then I didn't like it, but that doesn't stop me from hating everything else. I recently dug out the ending credits and it was so heartwarming.
I still have never played Yoshi's Island DS for some reason... did the game perform poorly in sales? Seems it fell into obscurity.
-
It wasn't very good.
-
Do you just have a problem with everything good?
-
I thought Yoshi's Island DS was good, just not very good. I think some of the reason people say YI DS wasn't good was because YI SNES was so very good, and some people may also be prejudiced based on who made the game.
-
I just got really tired of it about midway through world 3. Nothing against Artoon on my part at least.
-
I can only imagine the tone and the face as she said "HEY! HEY! HEY!" I think many of us agree that sound was really annoying, probably a low point for the game. Nintendo Power also said something about it. I wish I could remember what it was, but I think it was "Baby Mario's wailing is the most annoying sound in the universe." I think one interview said the sound was intentionally made that annoying so you'd want to catch Baby Mario sooner. I think it was supposed to set off some primal or motherly instinct, but no, we really wanted to get Mario to stop that whining. Or we'd let him get caught by the Toadies ("I'm not gonna lie, I'll not be a gentleman"... *cough*) and let the whining become their problem.
Reminds me when Perfect Dark was going through another delay (argh, Rare...) and the PDark forums theorized the reason for the delay wasn't to make the game more polished, it was to make Grimshaw's voice more annoying.
Great idea to refer to it as a singing tape. Can't wait to hear a remix where someone mixes Mario's whine in with some other song and doesn't make it annoying.
-
Yoshi's Island DS was irrationally difficult in most places, the music was very crude and limited, there were somehow less non-bonus levels than the original, and the graphics were... well, they just weren't quite like the original. It wasn't a worthy successor (and I think they knew it--hence the name change from "Yoshi's Island 2"), but I've played worse.
-
Do you just have a problem with everything good?
BTW I was referring to Tv_Themes, not Chupperson.
-
I still think the name was changed because Yoshi's Story was kind of technically Yoshi's Island 2, but if they called it Yoshi's Island 3, they'd confuse most people and **** off the few that got that they were acknowledging Yoshi's Story (I actually liked YS, though). The only thing I didn't like about it was the baby-switching. Same thing as SM64DS; throwing in arbitrary obstacles and gimmicks just to force you to switch between characters. If each level was just one baby (and most of them were Mario), it would have been good. Also Luigi should have been playable.
Well, carryable, actually. You're really playing as the Yoshis, not the babies.
-
YIDS's graphics seem to have sacrificed its predecessor's squiggly, hand-drawn charm for clarity, which we can all agree sucks.
-
I liked the two-screen levels (and the ability to shift the top and bottom screens, even if it usually resulted in one screen being nothing but sky or dirt), though, and I can't recall "the gap" actually causing me much strife.
-
I thought Yoshi's Island DS was good, just not very good. I think some of the reason people say YI DS wasn't good was because YI SNES was so very good, and some people may also be prejudiced based on who made the game.
I agree, but in all honesty, Yoshi's Island DS is probably one of the best semi-sequels to a game that a third party developer ever made. Seriously. It may not be THE YS2, but it can definitely pass itself off. It's pretty hardcore. Though, it is difficult (in a good way, seriously, there aren't many difficult games). I never did manage to beat the last level, but it is a great, well-made game. If you haven't played the first, you should play it.
-
I actually wrote a review for YIDS on my LiveJournal at one point. I may have to dig that up.
-
This thread reminds me of something my mom said when MarioKart 64 first came out.
She picked me up from school the day after we got the Nintendo 64 and told me that she had been playing MarioKart 64 all day (no surprise since my mom has always been a video gamer, going all the way back to pong). When I asked how she did, she said she did fine but lost one of the races to "some guy who says 'ribbit' whenever he passes you".
To this day my mom still calls Donkey Kong "the ribbit guy" whenever she plays MarioKart 64 despite knowing now that it's Donkey Kong (which I guess she couldn't tell from behind him in MK64--I'm pretty sure she knew who DK was long before the N64 thanks to the arcade game).
-
I completely forgot that Yoshi's Island DS existed, and furthermore that I owned it. Thanks for reminding me. I'm gonna start playing again for sure.