EDIT: I've found a name for this story. If the title doesn't make sense, it's because it was the only catchy alliteration that I could find appropriate for this story. Lack of feedback can really kill a story. I had nearly forgotten this. Because Area 64 asked what happened to this story, I'll try to revive it.
Once upon a time, there lived a peach and a pizza in the Refrigerator Kingdom. The peach and pizza loved each other very much. The peach was always getting kidnapped by a jar of pickled herring. The pizza would throw his spicy, hot pepperoni at the fiendish herring and get his beloved fruit back for his rich, brown crust to wrap around. On the night before their expiration dates, the three foods made a simple wish: to live longer lives; to become animate creatures.
The next morning, the pizza woke up to a new environment. His beloved peach wasn't by his side. He jumped--wait! He jumped! (so high that his head hit the ceiling) Pizzas don't jump! In fact, he felt limbs that pizzas don't have. He had appendages! He hopped out of his bed (an actual bed, not a pizza box!), and walked, surprisingly well, to a nearby mirror. The pizza was shocked at what he saw: rich, uncombed, curly brown hair, a full, bushy, black mustache, two sparkling, blue eyes, two round ears, a mouth, human skin tone, and a button round nose! He couldn't call himself a pizza anymore. A meatball, perhaps, since he found that had he had a belly round as one, but no, he was human! What should he call himself? On his bed stand he noticed a red hat with a 'M' etched above the bill. He put the hat on, and chimed "It's-a me, Mario!"
But what about my darling peach, Mario thought. Was her wish granted? Before he could think anymore of the matter, a slightly taller, thinner human in green clothing walked into our hero's room. "Are you just gonna stare at your reflection all morning and let your breakfast go cold? That's not like the brother I know."
Brother? The red hero stared at this new person. The human shared a deep resemblance to our hero. His hat had a 'L' etched above the bill, his mustache was shaped slightly differently, and his disposition was a little more lanky, but Mario could tell that this was his...
"Little Brother!" Mario embraced his brother. "I thought the people ate you up!"
"What are you talking about, Mario?" the taller human shoved his older brother off. "Get your coffee in before you speak any more nonsense! I swear, you're always delirious when you're hungry!"
Mario felt his abdomen area rumble. Was that the hunger sensation? The thought of eating food, at first, felt cannibalistic to our hero, but he realized that humans needed food in order to survive. He was no longer a pizza. Was his wish actually granted or was this the foods' afterlife?
To be continued
EDIT2: connected the first two chapters into one chapter.