15
« on: November 01, 2009, 07:24:40 PM »
Both Super Mario Bros. 3 and Super Mario World are often referred to as Mario's best in 2D platforming, and rightfully so. Both games are huge leaps in the genre. But which one is your favorite?
Notice I did not say which one do you think is "better." I think that comparing the two now, Super Mario World's gameplay, with its expansive map and branching pathways, make it a clear winner. Despite this, however, I find that I still favor Super Mario Bros. 3. Why? I think it has to do with a combination of many elements. There is simply something about Super Mario Bros. 3, it's setting, atmosphere, and overall mood, that just puts a bigger smile on my face. Consider the story. We had to rescue the kings and restore peace to the entire Mushroom World! The princess wasn't even captured until later as a plot twist! I thought this was a very epic story for a Mario game, especially for an NES Mario game! Super Mario World's story wasn't quite as hooking for me.
Which is probably why I favor Super Mario Bros. 3. To me, the game just has more magical moments. Who could forget discovering the White Toad Houses, turning the Hammer Bros. into treasure ships, consistently finding new powerups like the Hammer Bros. suit and the Takooni Suit, and encountering Kuribo's Shoe, among other things? At least for me, Super Mario World's list does not go on as long. And who could forget the Chain Chomps, Boos, and Thwomps? Believe it or not, at one time these were all INTRODUCED into the Mario series, and now they've become nearly as classic as Goombas and Koopa Troopas.
The battle between Super Mario Bros. 3 and Super Mario World kind of resembles the battle between Donkey Kong Country 2 and Donkey Kong Country 3. While Donkey Kong Country 3 wins in the gameplay department, Donkey Kong Country 2's story and atmosphere makes it much more memorable. Donkey Kong Country 2 features a pirate-themed adventure where the heroes invade enemy territory to rescue Donkey Kong. Donkey Kong Country 3 felt more like "let's take a nature walk!" Not as memorable. Well, at this point I'm just rambling. So, what do you say?