I've felt like an outcast on this forum for many, many months before this thread was ever revived, and my differences in religion have basically no impact on these feelings. Although, this board isn't the only place I feel like this; not by a longshot.
The thing a lot of people who do not believe in evolution miss, from my experiences on the issue, is that evolution and natural selection take millions upon millions of years and several thousands of different mutations in order to yield the beings that exist today. You can't say that evolution happens in a few generations, or that your great grandpa was a monkey, because that isn't the case. It also doesn't help that the human race has excluded itself from natural selection in all but the most extreme cases. How many tigers do you think have imperfect vision? Almost none that can survive for any period of time. How many humans have imperfect vision? Almost all of them, from what I've seen. Think of evolution as many, many, many instances of natural selection in a string. And for every change that survives to yield the next, there's countless others that weren't as desirable that just died out.