New Yoshi Game

[Chupperson Weird]

Yes, right.

[goodie]

I guess that means Pixar movies aren't really 3d either, since they're prerendered.

[Chupperson Weird]

Yeah, and neither are polygon-rendered video games because they're displayed on a two-dimensional screen.
P.S. Depth is simulated in traditional animation and live action filming too, and they aren't 3D either, so your CG movie comment is totally out of place to begin with.

[goodie]

Well, you guys seemed to be saying that anything prerendered was not really 3d.

[Chupperson Weird]

Should have just added my last comment in this post.

[Linkin800]

But you call it that when there is some 3-D and some 2-D involved. Yoshi's Story, however, has no 3-D involved.

I think your forgeting the 3-D level select box's at the world maps.

[BP]

Oh yeah. But if that's enough to call Yoshi's Story 3-D then you could call Super Mario 64 2-D for its file select screen.

[Yoshi Spencer]

I would welcome another Yoshi game but I would like to see him have with a man's voice rather than that irritating baby'ish one, or revert him back to the dino noises that he used to make such as pre-Mario Kart 64 :). Also how about an old poppa-Yoshi?

[Chupperson Weird]

A man's voice? What?
Also, I think Kazumi Totaka is an excellent Yoshi voice.

[ShadowBrain]

I think your forgeting the 3-D level select box's at the world maps.

I think that's stretching it a little...

[MEGAߥTE]

Like SB said, Yoshi's Story was promoted as a 2.5D game.  Yes, it's not mathematically correct; it's marketing.
However, I seem to recall different paths at different depths you could take (sometimes blocked by that elephant), which would make it a little more than completely 2D, not including the graphics.

[carsr4carpeople1]

We definitely need another 2-d Yoshi game. Like a cool sidescroller for the Wii.... that would be awesome.

[dc804]

We havent had a 3-D yoshi platforming game yet. If it is on the Wii, you can use the Wiimote to aim where you throw your eggs.

[Vidgmchtr]

or revert him back to the dino noises that he used to make such as pre-Mario Kart 64 :).

I really don't like it when people say that those odd sounds Yoshi made before Yoshi's Story were his VOICE.

That sound Yoshi made (I'd rather not spell it out,) whenever Mario jumped on him was the sound his saddle made as Mario sat on it. Though not really canon, this also happened in the Super Mario World cartoons a lot. Yoshi had an actual voice in the cartoon, and that odd sound was made every time someone jumped on his saddle.

Why Nintendo decided to make this his "voice" later on is beyond me, and it always irritated me to hear that plus other odd noises coming from him in Mario Kart, Golf 64, and the first three Party games (Though those were made by Hudson, not Nintendo). I quite liked it when they gave him an actual voice in Yoshi's Story, and kept it over in the Gamecube era, and I'm assuming it'll be in Brawl as well.

[goodie]

Thing is, in Yoshi's Story, they were baby Yoshis, so a baby-sounding voice worked. But it seems a little odd to have the exact same voice for the adult Yoshis.