They claim to be making an RPG for the Atari 2600, but if you beleive that, the word "gullible" isn't in the dictionary either.
Yeah, that project never saw the light of day. They just couldn't fit an RPG onto the Atari.
A Homestar Runner game, eh? Well, knowing the Brothers Chap's style of humor, it'd be something weird like an action Turn-Based tactics ping-pong game or something. Even if were for the generation of consoles, it'd still feature graphics that look like they came straight out of the Atari ages (Strong Bad would've thought it was technical marvel). It would feature the twelve main characters from the start, and 8 unlockable characters, each with their own stories to follow. TBC would write the story, dialoge and jokes, and would supply the voiceover work.