Since the PS2 is so old, then why are people still buying it like it was just released? Okay, I admit the Xbox lacks in good games, but it makes up for that fact that it has the most powerful graphics processor ever made for a console! That can't be beat!
Also, the Box controller is big and bulky, but don't forget that Microsoft recently released the new smaller version called Controller S. I have used the new controller, and I think it is much better than the original for multiple reasons:
1. It is smaller (obviously) and easier to hold.
2. The A B X and Y buttons are smaller and positioned in a more traditional circular pattern.
3. The analog sticks are shaped so they fit your thumbs (it is much better than the round analog sticks of the old controller).
I actually prefer the Controller S over the PS2 controller (yes all the buttons on the XBox controllers are pressure sensitive) - the Controller S is easier to use and more comforatable to hold.
But the 'Cube beats all competitors! The controller is unmatched - perfect button layout and very comfortable, the games are the best of any first-party company, and Nintendo is known for making great game software...that's what has made them so successful over the years!
So, I would have to choose a GameCube for Nintendo's games - secondly, an XBox simply for the downloadable soundtrack feature and the great graphics power...
---