Overall, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic got best game of the year, which I disagree with.  Now don't get me wrong, I like Star Wars, but stuff that is 4,000 years or so before the movies is not my bag.  It's still a great game, but best? What I think is interesting (and suprising) is Wario Ware getting 2nd Best OVERALL!
Another thing: USA Today gave Viewtiful Joe Overall best game.