Print

Author Topic: How come good Mario games get bad reviews?  (Read 4601 times)

Insane Steve

  • Professional Cynic
« Reply #15 on: September 10, 2005, 09:46:41 AM »
Granted, people are entitled to their own opinions, but 6.3/10 is to me way too low for MK64. I mean, ya, mathematically 5 is average (Assuming the scale goes from 0.0-10; if it is 1.0-10, 5.5 is average), but when you throw out the bad games that the developers put no thought into, I'd put an average mark for a first party endeavor at about 7. And I thought MK64 was a much better game than a 6.3 -- what I like to do is compare other game with similar marks to the game to see how "far off" the rating is. Have a link?

As for the Mario Party games, I stick to my thought that MP4-6 would've gotten substantially higher marker had they been MP1-3, not 4-6. That is, most of the low marks are the reviewer's way of saying "This isn't original anymore, guys. Stop please." I actually remember, in a video game mag (I can't remember which one), a reviewer, as part of a joke after a review for MP5, said that  they'd give MP6 a score less than 2/10 (Under the assumption that the game couldn't possibly be made. Do not underestimate the lack of originality in anything today) if it did come out. Nintendo hasn't just made 6 of them -- they're now working on an 8th game in the series. (7 console ones and the advance one makes 8)

On this level, I have to concur with the editors: You can make 8 Mario Party games, and yet you can't even design a simple original 2D Mario platformer game for the GBA/GB:SP? [Bad place], I can design the levels for you if you're THAT scrapped for ideas!

You listening, Nintendo? ...

Of course not. Nintendo never listens to anyone anymore. Enjoy Mario Party 35.

~I.S.~

~Wow, I edited a mod's post... Please don't hurt me... >_>; ~Sapph

Edited by - Sapphira on 9/21/2005 6:43:58 PM
~I.S.~

« Reply #16 on: September 10, 2005, 12:55:50 PM »
You do realize that it's Hudson who develops the Mario Party games and not Nintendo right? and if they took suggestions from random people they'd probably screw themselves over even more?

 Kelso: Guys this is a game of Cat & Mouse between me & Hyde. I''m gonna make him admit he''s been going out with Jackie behind my back.
Fez: Guys, what happens in Cat & Mouse if the cat is retarded?
As a game that requires six friends, an HDTV, and skill, I can see why the majority of TMK is going to hate on it hard.

Print