Not sure if I'm a brony or not. Just because I've watched every episode of the show, want my friends to watch it, watched some episode commentaries, like the fan music, am waiting impatiently for season 3, took a picture with a young woman with a MLP backpack, donated to the bronycon documentary to see my name in the credits, and wore a brony bracelet when out of state doesn't necessarily mean... oh who am I kidding? What's happened to me?! *fake cries* lol
In all seriousness, I'm not sure if I need to label myself something for liking a good show. I guess I can understand since it's still weird to many people who first hear about it and giving yourself a name kind of makes you feel like you're part of a group. (And it's too bad every fandom has to have "those people" you don't want to talk about) But I like trying new things and this was something that I ended up liking after adjusting to the girlyness and added to my list of other interests like Mario. :) I'm also trying to get into Adventure Time but it's just too darn weird for my tastes, sorry. My favorite cartoons are those that are funny, random, and witty and aren't dumbed down. What really made me smile was when I learned that the voice actress for Twilight was also the same for Timmy Turner of the Fairly Odd Parents, my second favorite cartoon. (I watched an episode today and laughed through all of it)
Finally, I also have mild autism but don't think that plays a part in my liking it. I enjoy many kinds of shows, animated or rea life (though I don't really watch much TV), and don't feel like less of a man because I don't like shows with a lot of violence. Final final note... I hope Vinyl Scratch gets her own episode in season 3! Not likely but let me dream.