There's no way I could pick one from the last three options. New SMB, SPP, and M&LPiT are three games I fully intend on buying in the future. As for Basketball, well, I don't play the Mario sports games, other than if you count the Mario Kart games. Platform/Adventure/RPG Mario games I don't even bother renting anymore before I buy them, well, because I know I'll like them.