It's safe to say you'd recommend Midori Days then? I saw the first episode at Otakon, and a friend of mine is absolutely obsessed with the series. It looked to have a lot of comedy in store, but I could also see that ruined by an overly romantic overtone. I did enjoy Love Hina, however, so if it's anything like that, that'd be great.
As for my favorite Anime & Manga, I guess I would have to hand it over to Record of Lodoss War.