While the plot was a bit off in that game, I think the game looks get while you play it, and I like the gameplay where there's a main area like Delfino Plaza, Peach's Castle, or Gruntilda's Lair, and then there are a bunch of levels you go into that have individual tasks to collect stars, or shines or jiggies. So while I agree that Petey Piranha was too weird and sudden a character to be made a selectable character in MK:DD, I still think the game he came from had at least good gameplay. Nevermind the weird plot. At least I don't mind it...