I've never been a big fan of any video game based on a sport, really. Exceptions include most golf games (I.E., the Mario Golf series, though there are other I will play), and a couple of the really old baseball games.
I am also not a big fan od first person shooters. I just can't focus on them, that's all. Only one of those I ever played for a reasonable amount of time was Goldeneye (N64).
As for specific games, there aren't too many I can honestly say I loathe. Donkey Kong 64 severely dissapointed me, though.
~I.S.~