Here's some info that might be helpful:
Returning Members of 2012: (Note: dates are the month and year of these members' last posts before they returned, in Month/Year format. "Blast" means they only posted a handful of times within that period, "legit" means when they were last truly active. I only looked in the New/Returning Members thread, so I may have missed some members.)
~ Cora (?? [was previously banned and made a new account])
~ superstarMASIAH (8/11 blast, 11/10 legit)
~ Super Mario (6/08 blast, 8/07 legit)
~ Markio (12/08)
~ Yoshisaurus Rex (9/09 blast, 12/06 legit)
~ Suffix (8/10)
~ Sapphira (2/11 blast, 3/09 legit)
~ Frostbite (6/09)
~ Chupperson Weird (11/10)
~ Koopaslaya (6/11 blast, 10/10 legit)
~ Mr. Melee (5/10 blast, 7/08 legit)
~ FlamingBlueMario (3/11)
New Members of 2012 (who posted more than twice):AmbitiousShade, TheBowserMullet, zelkova, DRest806, randomuser2349, pocket_arsenal, Red Lewd Uganda, speedruntrainer, Crimson, TheColonelKR, Godot, Mason, Glowsquid, Clowny, Hello:), Ogres Have Layers, edward1978.
TheMightyThor joined/started posting at the tail-end of 2011 (12/13), so he may or may not qualify. Never mind. He's actually coolkid.
Sapphira's Votes:Poster of the Year: CrossEyed7
Post of the Year: Hmm... Well, I'd have to say
this post because it linked an article that resulted in me re-examining/shifting my perspective. Which I suppose is pretty life-changing. But I suppose, as far as actual content goes,
this post covers those ideas the best.
Topic of the Year: Sexual Orientation. Probably the only thread created
this year that held my interest and sparked both the most intellectual and personal (i.e. meaningful) conversations. Not to mention, for the most part, everyone's handled the controversial topic respectfully and maturely. Yeah, I may have created it, but everyone else helped sustain it and made it what it is.
Image of the Year: A Winner Is KuromatsuSig of the Year: Toad's: "I understand that [Toad] has some popularity. Somehow." ~ Shigeru Miyamoto
Song of the Year: "Waluigi's Island (a capella)" by Fifth (and teh_yoshi from the chatroom). It's so creepy and awesome at the same time!
Deezer Award: dezzer
Funniest Poster: Huh. Tough one. I guess maybe CrossEyed. I can't really think of anyone else who's said/posted funny stuff (in 2012). Which is actually kind of sad.
Most Creative Poster: Qwerty
Smartest Poster: CrossEyed7, although Markio has a lot of wisdom.
Most Amiable Poster: Markio
Best Newbie: Glowsquid (he's more active in the chatroom), Godot
Blast from the Past: Markio, by far the most active, quality-contributing returning member. And he's also been gone for 4 years!
Most Missed: Watoad. Also Black Mage.
Most Improved: TheMightyThor (AKA coolkid)
Most Mario-Wise Poster: CrossEyed7, The Chef
Meowiest Poster:Queen of Posters: Let's go with BP or The Chef. Naw, Markio for teh funnehz.
King of Posters: Sapphira. Voting for myself if only for the irony.
WTD Award: TheColonelKR
Retro AwardsDynamic Duo: The Chef & TheColonelKR
Best Custom Title: Ogres Have Layers - "Malaprop Monster"
Most Creepiest: [Man, that grammar bugs me.] Hello:)
Best Name: Ym9iYnlzcTEzMzc equalsign
Jeez, CrossEyed and Markio. Way to dominate the awards. :P